I hope this post stirs the pot a little and stimulates you to ask hard questions.
“Reward the smallest try.” That is a common mantra recited over and over in the horse training world. It’s a good concept that if followed can lead to a happy and contented horse. But what is a reward? Is it even a concept horse’s understand? I’m not so sure “reward” is the right term.
Mostly when I think of rewards I think of food rewards because they are easy to understand, but I think the ideas bouncing around in my head can equally pertain to other forms of reward such as the removal of pressure (negative reinforcement) or the addition of a pat or scratch (positive reinforcement) or a softly spoken kind word (such as “good boy”).
Humans think of a reward as a prize or gift for doing something right. It is a bonus prize intended to encourage us to keep doing well.
However, I don’t think horses view a reward in the same way that humans do. For example, if I gave a person a box of chocolates for the help they gave me, they would see the chocolates as a reward and feel good about helping me and feel better towards me. Yet if I gave a horse a slice of apple for coming up to me in the paddock, they see it no more as a reward than they do the grass in the paddock. There is no ‘thank you’ in the horse’s thinking when accepting the apple. A horse doesn’t think of me as a nicer person or better friend because I was the source of the apple. A horse thinks of me as no more than a delivery truck for apples.
Food is a very powerful motivator of behaviour. I believe it comes second in importance in modifying behaviour after safety and comfort. Eating is part of a horse’s primordial nature. They find the offer of food difficult to turn down. Even when their bellies are full I’ve never seen a horse knock back an offer of a carrot. It’s there for the taking and they take it because that's what horses do. A horse does not see the carrot as a reward, but as something to grab while it’s available. The need to eat is closely linked to the need to feel safe and comfortable. It is not a bonus treat. Similarly, removal of pressure is linked to a horse’s sense of safety and comfort and is likewise not a reward but a basic need.
In my mind, I think the conversation inside a horse’s mind goes something like this.
Horse: “Hey, give me a carrot.”
Trainer: “No. You’re not trying hard enough.”
Horse: “Bastard. Okay, what if I stop moving? Now give me a carrot.”
Trainer: “That’s a better try.” The trainer offers a carrot.
Horse: “Finally! What took so long? Give me another carrot.”
This is what I think is the conversation inside some people’s minds.
Horse: “Hey boss, you’re looking good. Can I please have a carrot?”
Trainer: “I’d like to give you a carrot. I really would, but could you please try a little hard?”
Horse: “Okay, I’ll try to stop moving. Now can I please have a carrot?”
Trainer: “What a good boy. Here’s your reward.”
Horse: “Thank you. You are so good to me. I love you and will try even harder next time – cross my eyes and hope to die. BTW, have you been working out?”
You could just as easily substitute the offer of a carrot with the release of the reins or something similar.
So why does any of this matter? Are we just talking semantics?
To a certain extent, I think it doesn’t matter if you call the addition of a positive stimulus or removal of a negative stimulus a reward or release, or relief or any ‘r’ word you choose. The way we use these training principles is more important than the titles we give them. However, in another sense words do matter because they influence attitudes.
To give somebody a reward connotes of giving them something they are not normally entitled to – a gift, something special. But horses have no concept of a gift. By using terms like reward we think we are doing something nice for our horse, yet a horse thinks no such thing. What we view as a kindness towards our horse, our horse views as an entitlement.
I don’t know how many times over the years I have heard people tell me about all the nice things they do for their horses. But of course, horses don’t think like people want them to think. Horses don’t view the things we do as kindness or otherwise. They don’t judge us as a caring owner or not. They simply take the viewpoint that what we do for them and to them as life presenting more comfort or less comfort.
There are potential side effects from thinking of the removal of a negative or the addition of a positive stimulus as a reward. Sometimes (without even being aware of it) an attitude creeps into our thinking that a horse should be thankful for all the rewards we have given it. When a horse is difficult or disobedient the word ‘ungrateful’ can pass through our minds. If this happens it is easy to get angry and even use punishment to change a horse’s behaviour.
I think the point I’m trying to make is that even though we talk about rewarding a horse for its effort, as an essential element of the training process the concept is entirely foreign to horses. How much this affects how we apply a reward will depend on how much emotion we attach to the term.
I know many will want to argue that their bible of horse behaviour or the greatest minds in ethology will disagree with me. That’s okay. I don’t care because I am not arguing about an academic opinion. I’m talking about what my experience has taught me about how horses think. There is a difference believe it or not.
